First, thank you for applying
If you're reading this, you likely applied to have your property listed on Stays and received a decline. We know that stings, even a little. Putting your property forward and hearing "not a fit" isn't fun, no matter how it's framed.
This article is our attempt to be fully transparent about why declines happen, what a decline does and doesn't say about your property, and what you can do next. Some of this is Stays-specific. A lot of it is honest advice about running a great vacation rental business, wherever you run it.
The Stays standard
Stays is a curated discovery platform, not an aggregator. We aim to list what we believe are the top ~20% of vacation rentals, which means we say no to many properties that are perfectly good businesses.
A decline from Stays isn't a judgment that your property is bad. It's a judgment about fit with what travelers come to Stays looking for: design-forward stays, unique settings, memorable experiences, properties worth traveling for specifically. If your stay serves a different (and valid) traveler, being on Stays wouldn't help you much anyway.
It's also worth knowing that a decline is one of three possible results. Applications that meet our requirements but don't clear the full bar usually receive Limited status instead, which keeps a live, shareable Listing Page. A decline means we couldn't offer that middle path. The full decision framework is laid out in our Acceptance Guide.
Why applications get declined
Declines come from two directions.
Several quality gaps at once
A single shortfall usually lands at Limited, not Declined. A property that's solid but not distinctive still gets a Listing Page. Declines happen when several gaps stack together: a property without a defining feature, presented with weak photos, in an unremarkable setting, with thin details. At that point there's no realistic version of the page that would represent the property well or serve travelers honestly, so we decline rather than publish something that helps nobody.
If this was your situation, the good news is that most of these gaps are fixable, and the fixes (better photography, sharper presentation, leaning into what's genuinely unique) improve your bookings everywhere, not just on Stays.
A hard disqualifier
Some things lead to a decline on their own, regardless of everything else:
- Unverifiable listing information. We verify applications against the live web. If key details or your connection to the property can't be confirmed, we can't list it.
- Broken or misleading links. Booking and social links that don't work, or don't go where they claim, end reviews quickly. Every link on a Stays Listing Page has to be worth a traveler's click.
- Offensive content. Inappropriate material in the application itself or on any linked website or social account.
- Unwillingness to make requested revisions. Many applications get a revision request before any decision. If the changes we ask for don't get made, we can't move the application forward.
- Very poor photo content. When photos are so limited or low-quality that the property can't be evaluated at all, we have nothing to review. This is among the most common and most fixable reasons.
- Property condition concerns. Spaces that appear unsanitary, damaged, or poorly maintained.
- Shared rooms or single-bedroom rentals. Stays lists entire, self-contained properties only. Guests must have the whole space to themselves.
- Not vacation rental oriented. Long-term housing, corporate housing, and event-only venues serve real needs, but not the one Stays serves.
The first six are fixable or situational. The last two are structural: if your property falls in those categories, reapplying won't change the outcome, and we'd rather be straight about that than invite wasted effort.
What you can do next
If the reason was fixable, address it and reapply
There's no cooldown period for reapplying, though we'd suggest giving it a few months so changes (new photos, updated links, a refreshed presentation) are actually in place before you resubmit. Reapplications get the same full review as first-time applications, and a stronger second application often lands differently than the first. However, repetitively reapplying with basically the same application can get you removed from the Stays platform altogether. So be strategic with this.
Invest in photography first
If you take one action, take this one. Professional photography typically runs $300-$800 for a full property shoot and is the single highest-ROI investment a vacation rental host makes. Better photos raise your conversion on every channel you're on, not just Stays. If it's not in budget yet: shoot in natural light, declutter every surface, use a wide angle, and take 30-50 photos, not 8.
Give your property its own brand
A property Instagram account with a real name (think @thecarpenterscabin, not a keyword string), a clear bio, and a dozen good photos is a compounding asset. So is a direct booking option through software like Lodgify, Hostfully, or OwnerRez. Both make any future application stronger, and both grow your business independent of any platform's decision.
Think in years, not months
The hosts who build real, sustainable vacation rental businesses do it over 3-5 years. Every improvement compounds: better photos, active social, a direct booking option, refined design details, honest reviews from happy guests. The property that gets declined this year can be a strong applicant next year with those improvements in place.
Get honest feedback and listen to it
Ask a friend outside of hosting to look at your photos and description with fresh eyes. Ask a past guest what they'd tell someone considering booking. Ask a photographer or interior designer what they'd change. Real, non-flattering feedback is the fastest path to improvement.
If you want more hands-on help
Stays selectively takes on marketing support engagements for hosts and property managers who want more than the free platform tools: brand consulting, content strategy, photography referrals, direct booking site builds, and social media growth support. We keep these engagements limited to keep the work high-quality. If you're interested, email hello@stays.co with a quick note about your property and what kind of support you're looking for.
Closing
Getting a "no" from a curated platform isn't a knock on your business. It's information about fit. The best hosts we know have been told "no" by platforms, publications, or partners at some point, and used those moments to sharpen what they were building.
If your property serves a real traveler need, keeps guests happy, and generates the revenue you want, a Stays decline doesn't change any of that. If our feedback gives you a direction to sharpen the property, the photos, or the marketing, even better.
We're rooting for you either way.




